CAF-7 · Chapter 6 · Question 15 of 15
When applying Tucker’s 5-question model, if a proposed course of action results in a 'No' answer to one of the questions (e.g., it is profitable but not fair), what does this indicate?
Test yourself: pick an answer
Reveal answer & explanation
Correct answer: C) The decision-maker faces an ethical dilemma and must carefully weigh the conflicting values
Explanation
Tucker's model rarely produces a perfect 'Yes' to all five questions. When values conflict (e.g., an action is profitable but not fair), it highlights the core of the ethical dilemma, requiring the decision-maker to justify prioritizing one value over another.
More Ethical Decision Making Models MCQs
- Q2A CFO discovers that the company's new product has a minor safety defect. Fixing it would cost millions, while ignoring it might only…
- Q3Which of the following represents the first step in the American Accounting Association (AAA) 7-step model for ethical decision making?
- Q4An internal auditor identifies a financial irregularity but is threatened with termination if she reports it. In the AAA model, during…
- Q5According to the ICAP study text, which of the following is the most refined definition of ethics proposed by Trevino and Nelson?
- Q6In the AAA 7-step model, what is the primary purpose of Step 6: 'Assess the consequences'?